Data disputesBeta

Public read-only log of conflicts the resolver flagged across the Civica source allowlist. Open disputes await human review; resolved disputes carry an outcome and methodology rationale; auto-resolved disputes were closed by the staleness cron after the resolver stopped emitting them. Reviewer identity is redacted on this surface.

These disputes are part of the reconciliation methodology under active revision. The resolver, source allowlist, and material-error thresholds may change in future methodology version bumps (currently v0.2-beta). See the full reconciliation methodology for context.

33 total disputes on record·Showing 5 of 5 (filtered)·Page 1 of 1

SortSeverityNewestOldest
StatusAllOpenResolvedAuto-resolved
SeverityAnyLowMidHighExtreme
KindAllMaterial errorEnvelope rejectGroup A overrideGroup C overrideRank demotedPublic correctionOther
GroupAnyABC
Fact-keyAnypublic_debt_pct_gdp (23)inflation_rate (6)population_total (3)gdp_per_capita_usd (1)
Source pairAnycia_factbook × imf_weo (29)cia_factbook × world_bank (3)cia_factbook × un_data (1)
AgeAny0-7d7-30d30-90d90d+
Marshall Islandspopulation_total· created May 4, 2026
1.20× thresholdMaterial errorGroup BAuto-resolvedauto_resolve_stale

Material-error rejection: 33000 from imf_weo differs from 82,011 (2024 est.) (cia_factbook) beyond the per-fact threshold.

A · cia_factbook
82,011 people
as of 2024-01-01
B · imf_weo
33,000 people
as of 2031-01-01
OutcomeAuto-resolved (stale)· May 5, 2026
Yemengdp_per_capita_usd· created May 4, 2026
1.10× thresholdMaterial errorGroup BAuto-resolvedauto_resolve_stale

Material-error rejection: 1692.308 from imf_weo differs from $200 (2024 est.) (cia_factbook) beyond the per-fact threshold.

A · cia_factbook
200 USD
as of 2024-01-01
B · imf_weo
1,692.308 USD
as of 2031-01-01
OutcomeAuto-resolved (stale)· May 5, 2026
Marshall Islandspopulation_total· created May 4, 2026
1.08× thresholdMaterial errorGroup BOpen

Material-error rejection: 37548 from un_data differs from 82,011 (2024 est.) (cia_factbook) beyond the per-fact threshold.

A · cia_factbook
82,011 people
as of 2024-01-01
B · un_data
37,548 people
as of 2024-01-01
Audit history

No audit entries on this dispute. The audit log starts at 2026-05-05; pre-R.21 reviewer decisions are recoverable from the resolution metadata above.

Marshall Islandspopulation_total· created May 3, 2026
1.08× thresholdMaterial errorGroup BOpen

Material-error rejection: 37548 from world_bank differs from 82,011 (2024 est.) (cia_factbook) beyond the per-fact threshold.

A · cia_factbook
82,011 people
as of 2024-01-01
B · world_bank
37,548 people
as of 2024-01-01
Venezuelapublic_debt_pct_gdp· created May 4, 2026
0.90× thresholdMaterial errorGroup BAuto-resolvedauto_resolve_stale

Material-error rejection: 308.7 from imf_weo differs from 38.9% of GDP (2017 est.) (cia_factbook) beyond the per-fact threshold.

A · cia_factbook
38.9 % of GDP
B · imf_weo
308.7 % of GDP
as of 2025-01-01
OutcomeAuto-resolved (stale)· May 5, 2026

Cite this page

Cite this pageAPA · BibTeX · Chicago · JSON
Civica. (2026). Civica Atlas Reconciled v0.2-beta — vintage 2026-Q1: Data disputes log. Civica Atlas. Retrieved May 7, 2026, from https://civicaatlas.org/factbook/methodology/reconciliation/disputes